Thursday, October 1, lecture 2 of 8
Useless Gourds, an Unbothered Monk, and Cook Ding's Knife
Webb finishes chapter 1 and begins chapter 3. He reviews the 'assault on common sense' and the quail/Confucian-official link, then uses Huizi's huge gourd and the chapped-hands salve to argue that usefulness and uselessness are imposed by narrow, conventional perspectives, not inherent in things. Song Rongzi's indifference to praise and blame is illustrated with the Zen story of Hakuin and the false paternity accusation ('Is that so?'). The point is equanimity toward both condemnation and praise. The second half is a close reading of Cook Ding: virtuosity acquired in stages, perception by spirit (shen) rather than the eyes, following the 'heavenly pattern' (tianli), and analogies to being 'in the zone' in sports, music and cooking.
鹏1. Free and Easy Wandering刀3. The Secret of Caring for Life
These notes are an AI summary of Zoom's automatic transcript, not checked against the recording. Speech recognition garbles names and words, so a detail can be wrong. Each segment has its timestamp: check it in the recording before relying on it.
- 00:52
Review: the assault on common sense
- Zhuangzi gives us ideas and language meant to jar us out of what we take for granted.
- Our reflexive judgments, from small/large, long/short and old/young up to fame vs. anonymity and success vs. failure, may be more arbitrary than we think: a matter of perspective or positionality, one angle among many.
- If the first pages of chapter 1 confused you, 'you're in very good company'. People have struggled with this text for a long time.
- 03:36
Water and wind 'piled up deep'; review of the quail
Chapter 1The Fish That Became a BirdThe Cicada, the Dove and the Quail Laugh
- He reads: if water isn't 'piled up deep enough' it can't float a big boat. A cup of water poured into a hollow floats bits of trash, but the cup itself sticks fast. Likewise, Peng needs 90,000 li of wind piled under him before he can shoulder the blue sky and head south.
- This is an odd 'textual moment' that shows the weird editing: basically the same example, with the self-satisfied 'junior' or 'apprentice' quails, appears twice.
- Review question: what links the quail to the Confucian officials? A student said that being small, they can't fathom something so big. Webb added the arrogance and self-satisfaction they share ('I do the best sort of flying').
- Reading tip: unlike the Analects there are no numbered passages, so gaps between paragraphs mark new sections. That can be confusing when a section starts at the top of a page.
- 07:49
Reading: Huizi's huge gourd and the chapped-hands salve
Chapter 1Huizi's Giant Gourd and the Chapped-Hands Salve
- Page 28. Huizi (Hui Tzu) tells Zhuangzi that the King of Wei gave him seeds for a huge gourd holding five piculs. A gourd cut in half and hardened becomes a vessel or dipper. This one was too heavy to use as a water jar and too unwieldy as a dipper, so he smashed it as useless.
- Huizi makes two judgments: the gourd is very big, and therefore it is totally useless and should be destroyed.
- Zhuangzi: 'You certainly are dense when it comes to using big things!' A family in Song made a salve for chapped hands and used it for generations to bleach silk. A traveler bought the recipe for 100 measures of gold and gave it to the King of Wu, who used it in a winter naval battle against Yue and won. The traveler was rewarded with a fief.
- Same salve, different uses. Why not make the gourd a great tub and go floating on the rivers and lakes? 'You still have a lot of underbrush in your head.'
“Obviously, you still have a lot of underbrush in your head.”
- 12:17
Usefulness is imposed, not inherent
Chapter 1Huizi's Giant Gourd and the Chapped-Hands Salve
- He asks what connects the two anecdotes. A student said that both owners assumed the object had a single use. Webb reframed this as suspending judgment: don't decide immediately that gourds are for dipping, try it once, and then call it useless.
- Broaden your conception of the problem and of possible solutions. The answer depends on how someone looks at the gourd, not on something inherent in the gourd. It is a matter of perception and of willingness to imagine other solutions before judging.
- The salve family's narrowness came from conventional thinking: 'that's the way we've always used it'. Tradition fixed the use until an outsider saw another one.
- General principle: objects, and some ideas too, are not inherently useful or useless, good or bad. We impose those values, and they come from position and perspective, not from the object.
- Link to the Carlin drivers: 'gourds are for dipping, salves are for bleaching' is the same solipsistic, me-centered assumption of correctness that blinds us to possibilities. The first step in evolving cognitively is to identify such judgments as narrow and biased.
“These judgments of good and bad and useless and useful are products of perspectives, products of one's position, as opposed to being inherent to the object itself.”
- 18:36
Song Rongzi: unmoved by praise or blame
Chapter 1The Ladder of Freedom: Song Rongzi, Liezi and the Perfect Man
- He returns to the paragraph after the official passage: Song Rongzi (Sung Jung-tzu) would burst out laughing at such a man.
- 'The whole world could praise him and it wouldn't make him exert himself; the whole world could condemn him and it wouldn't make him mope.' He drew a clear line between internal and external and recognized the boundaries of true glory and disgrace, 'but there was still ground left unturned.'
- We know little about this figure. Webb's reading is that he is almost impervious to what others think: insult and ridicule don't bother him, and praise doesn't move him. He has found a different way of relating to the world.
- Webb calls this detail 'very, very easy to overlook' and illustrates it with a story.
- 20:44
Hakuin and the false accusation: 'Is that so?'
- Hakuin (白隐, 17th–18th century Japanese Zen monk) was gifted at sutra language and dialogues with his master and was charismatic and in demand as a teacher. To escape the busyness he secretly moved to an abandoned temple in a small village, but word spread and young monks came to study with him.
- A shopkeeper's teenage daughter became pregnant and named Hakuin as the father. The furious parents confronted him. When the baby was born, the townspeople brought it to him. Each time he only said 'Is that so?'
- His students left. He went begging for alms, now also asking households for mother's milk, and was treated as a fraud of a priest. He raised the child until it was walking.
- Years later the daughter saw her son playing outside the temple, broke down, and admitted the father was the son of the family running the fish market. The family and townspeople apologized and took the child back. Hakuin again said 'Is that so?' and nothing more.
- The townspeople then decided a saint lived among them, someone superhuman. Even that praise meant nothing to him.
- 29:32
The lesson: equanimity toward both condemnation and praise
Chapter 1The Ladder of Freedom: Song Rongzi, Liezi and the Perfect Man
- Song Rongzi and Hakuin share an indifference to public opinion so sharp that being condemned or praised has no meaning.
- When falsely accused, 99.9% of people reflexively deny it. Hakuin doesn't. When vindicated, the impulse is 'I told you so', and he doesn't do that either. Being called superhuman gives him zero satisfaction. Webb calls this an emotional or spiritual 'evolved status'.
- This is the key psychological takeaway for Zhuangzi and for the Zen thought he influenced. It is not the friend's cliché 'it'll be all right, look on the bright side'. Coping with bad things is only half of it.
- The other half: on days of gushing happiness or success, Zhuangzi and Hakuin would say 'settle it down'. The delight may not last, may not be as great as you think, and may lead to things that aren't great at all.
- They reject both poles: neither crushed by bad remarks nor carried into euphoria by good ones. When some students compared it to Stoicism, Webb said 'possibly', but asked them to keep going and see how Zhuangzi handles these dichotomies.
“It's not simply a matter of not letting bad remarks bother you. It's also a matter of not letting good things cause you to reach some kind of euphoria.”
- 34:18
Into chapter 3: 'The Secret of Caring for Life'
Chapter 3Cook Ding Carves the Ox
- Page 46. Watson's title is 'The Secret of Caring for Life', but 'Secret of Nurturing Life' (养生主) is probably better.
- Cook Ting = Cook Ding (庖丁). Wade-Giles often writes a D sound with a T, as in Tao/Dao.
- The anecdote is so famous that he is 'compelled to teach it', with apologies to vegetarians.
- 36:05
Cook Ding's performance: craft as choreographed dance
Chapter 3Cook Ding Carves the Ox
- He reads: every touch of the hand, heave of the shoulder, move of the feet and thrust of the knee goes 'zip! zoop!' in perfect rhythm, like the Mulberry Grove dance or the Jingshou music. Lord Wenhui says: 'Imagine skill reaching such heights!'
- This is a portrait of a master craftsman doing something hard to get right the first time. Compare a restaurant fish-cutter who must maximize yield, while a layperson cuts, backs up and recuts.
- Caveat about 'dance': ancient court dance was highly choreographed, like ballet, not free-form. The comparison means that no movement is wasted and every movement has a purpose, which makes the body look elegant.
- 40:13
Cook Ding explains: 'What I care about is the Way'
Chapter 3Cook Ding Carves the Ox
- The virtuoso explains himself, and each sentence matters. 'What I care about is the Way, which goes beyond skill.' Webb notes it is 'the way with a capital W'.
- 'When I first began cutting up oxen, all I could see was the ox itself. After three years I no longer saw the whole ox. And now I go at it by spirit and don't look with my eyes. Perception and understanding have come to a stop and spirit moves where it wants.'
- 'I go along with the natural makeup, strike in the big hollows, guide the knife through the big openings, and follow things as they are,' never touching even a ligament or tendon.
- The knife: a good cook changes his knife once a year because he cuts, and a mediocre cook once a month because he hacks. Ding's knife has lasted 19 years and thousands of oxen, because a blade with no thickness inserted into the spaces between joints has more than enough room to play about.
“What I care about is the Way, which goes beyond skill.”
- 42:17
Stages of virtuosity and the change in perception
Chapter 3Cook Ding Carves the Ox
- This is a graded path to virtuosity. Ding didn't wake up with a knack. There was an apprenticeship, an intermediate stage and an advanced stage, and three tiers are probably a simplification.
- Virtuosity is acquired through repetition. You don't start at the top.
- As expertise grows, the way of perceiving changes: first the whole ox, then (probably) only the part being worked on, and finally perception by spirit (shen 神) with vision and hearing suspended.
- 44:37
'In the zone': the Olympic swimmer, Yo-Yo Ma, student performers
Chapter 3Cook Ding Carves the Ox
- A former student who swam in the Olympics was asked what he felt on the block before an international race with the crowd roaring. He said 'I feel nothing... I hear nothing'. Everything shuts off until he touches the wall, and then he suddenly hears the crowd.
- Webb's point: it isn't only confidence from practice. Self-consciousness is removed in the moment, distractions shut down, and you are almost transported to another realm, what athletes call 'being in the zone'.
- Yo-Yo Ma at Carnegie Hall might well say he isn't thinking about anything because the music is so internalized.
- A student actor/singer said they are fully in the zone on stage but get distracted, wondering what people think, when playing an instrument they have less experience with. They haven't reached the threshold. A student performer in arena competitions said nerves vanish once announced, muscle memory takes over, and afterward they can't remember the routine until they see the video playback.
- 50:16
The paradox: the zone can't be forced; losing the self
Chapter 3Cook Ding Carves the Ox
- Steph Curry's last minutes against France in the Olympics show a virtuoso in the zone. The counterexample is young baseball pitchers who dominate for three or four years, 'fall out of the zone', and try everything to get back.
- The zone can't be forced. It has a 'go with the flow' quality, and being self-conscious about getting back into it can be detrimental. That is the paradox.
- Who we are as individuals is largely built from accumulated sensory input (what we see, hear, feel, taste) over our lifetimes. An activity that shuts those inputs down means temporarily losing oneself in what one is doing.
- Even when Ding meets a complicated place, sizes up the difficulties and works slowly until the ox falls apart 'like a clod of earth crumbling to the ground', his seeing is not ordinary 'look at that' seeing.
- 54:09
Tianli, the heavenly pattern: radiologists, Michelangelo, cooks
Chapter 3Cook Ding Carves the Ox
- Watson's 'natural makeup' translates tianli (天理). Tian is sky or heaven (without Christian connotations), and li (理) is pattern, so it means a heavenly or master pattern.
- After enough carcasses, Ding perceives the subtle variations among them, as all humans share skeletons but differ in posture and musculature. A radiologist learns to tell a 'regular irregularity' from a 'really irregular irregularity'. A master pattern emerges from the accumulation of particulars, but it isn't visible to everyone.
- Michelangelo saw the sculpture as already in the marble and only peeled away the stone. The pattern already exists and the artist reveals it, rather than imposing genius on a blank slab.
- Virtuosos in any field (sports, dance, music, acting) discern these hidden or heavenly patterns and act according to them instead of an instruction handbook.
- Cooking analogy: first you follow the cookbook step by step, then you tweak it (more or less garlic), and finally the principles are so internalized that you need no manual. At a dinner party you can say 'too salty? add a little vinegar'.
“That pattern is already there in existence. I'm just going to reveal it.”
- 59:32
Watch for other virtuosi; closing; a student's question about Confucian overlap
Chapter 3Cook Ding Carves the Ox
- Zhuangzi will show other virtuosi (craftsmen) and put them to a larger purpose. As you read other sections, look out for figures Zhuangzi seems to admire who have 'dialed in something' beyond skill.
- Ask what in your own life or culture resonates with this ancient concept.
- After class, a student asked whether Cook Ding should be read against Confucian moral models. Webb said we know nothing about Ding outside his craft, not even whether he is a good family man, only that he is excellent at it. Confucianism and this ideal will overlap, but hold off on integrating them or treating it simply as an alternative mode absent from the Analects until later.