Test 2: Zhuangzi
Thursday, October 29, 12:30–1:50 PM, in class
Burton Watson, Chuang Tzu, Sections 1–6 (chapter 7 is not on the test)
Format
Analysis of selected passages. In lecture he described four excerpted passages, of which you write on three, each a sustained mini-essay of roughly 350 words (up to about 500). There are no targeted prompts, only a general preamble.
Bring
- Writing utensils and an eraser
- One 8½ × 11 sheet with handwritten notes on one side only
Provided
- Bluebooks
- Blank paper for outlining
- A clock
Turn in
- The test paper with the academic integrity pledge signed
- Your bluebook(s)
- Your notes sheet
- Your name on every item
What every answer has to do
What he said in lecture about how passages are graded. Each essay kit below is built around these steps.
- 1
Command of the details
Show you know the passage closely: who the characters are to each other, what happens, and what that implies. Not plot summary.
Said on Oct 15, Oct 22, Oct 27
- 2
Make sense of it
Explain what the passage is doing, as if to a curious, sympathetic outsider who has never taken the class.
Said on Oct 15, Oct 27
- 3
Connect it
Tie it to other passages by theme, image or formula: how are they alike, how do they differ, and what is Zhuangzi telling us? The best answers do both close reading and connection.
Said on Oct 22, Oct 27
- 4
Know how it ends
Long passages may be excerpted. Show you know the rest of the story.
Said on Oct 27
The guidance from lecture comes from AI summaries of Zoom's auto-transcripts. The logistics and topics come from the official info sheet.
The passages most likely to appear
Ranked by how much class time each got and what he flagged. Each one has an essay kit: close reading, how it ends, connections and an example answer.
Most likely
- Chapter 3Cook Ding Carves the OxHe called it a must-know that he is "compelled to teach", spent most of a lecture on it and came back to it in four later classes. Those returns linked it to the fasting of the mind and called it the "glimpse" of the True Man's unity. The info sheet also asks about it by name.
- Chapter 4Yan Hui and the Fasting of the MindAbout 32 minutes on Oct 20, then reused in the final review as Portrait C, "Confucius as Zhuangzian mentor". There he corrected a student who called it "aspirant" and told another not to call Confucius inconsistent ("don't go there").
- Chapter 5Shentu Jia and the Prime Minister: A Mirror Without DustAbout 42 minutes across three lectures. He twice quoted a former student's test answer calling the prime minister a "spiritual amputee" as the kind of insight he rewards, and in the final review he named its contrast with Toeless as "good to know".
- Chapter 6Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping MetalAbout 37 minutes. He used it for a "tight textual analysis" to model the method he grades by, previewed it as the body-as-temporary-home lesson, and in the final review said he would "not be surprised" if death came up on the exam "in some way or another".
- Chapter 6Singing Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the RealmMore class time than any other story (about 68 minutes over four lectures). It opened the Zhuangzi unit, came back as the "humble Confucius" portrait, was the passage he used to model how to analyse a passage, and returned in the final review as Portrait B. It also covers death, the critique of ritual and a Confucius portrait all at once.
Also likely
- Chapter 1The Cicada, the Dove and the Quail LaughWebb used it to launch the course's first big idea, relativity of judgment. He paired it with George Carlin's drivers ('I drive just right'), revealed the 'punchline' that the accomplished Confucian official is the quail, and returned to it in the 10/27 review as the model case of critiquing the big/small binary.
- Chapter 1The Ladder of Freedom: Song Rongzi, Liezi and the Perfect ManOn 10/1 Webb spent significant time on Song Rongzi, calling the detail 'very, very easy to overlook'. He illustrated it with the Zen monk Hakuin ('Is that so?') and drew the 'two halves' of equanimity: not crushed by blame, not carried away by praise.
- Chapter 1Huizi's Giant Gourd and the Chapped-Hands SalveWebb read it aloud in class (packet p. 28), asked what connects the gourd and the salve, and drew his rule that usefulness is imposed by perspective, not inherent in the object. His notes say to know it and be able to link it to the Carlin drivers and the quail.
- Chapter 2“This” and “That” and the Hinge of the WayAbout 21 minutes: the water-bottle demonstration and the two-tier vs. three-tier languages survey on Oct 20, then "words are not just wind" and the hinge on Oct 22, when he told anyone who missed it to watch the recording. On Oct 27 he said invoking "this and that" is welcome if you understand it.
- Chapter 2Zhuang Zhou Dreams He Is a ButterflyWebb called it probably the most famous anecdote in the Zhuangzi. He discussed it on 10/22 as the close of Chapter 2, stressing the relation between dreaming and waking, the recurring dream motif (the shrine oak) and the Transformation of Things (物化).
- Chapter 4Carpenter Shi and the Shrine OakWebb opened the 10/20 class with it (p. 59), calling it 'multifaceted', and built the whole uselessness discussion around it with Crippled Shu ('Useful, useless, to whom?'). On 10/27 he praised a student's link between the oak and Ai Taituo as exactly the kind of cross-episode connection he wants.
- Chapter 5Wang Tai, the One-Footed Teacher, and the Still WaterAbout 24 minutes in five segments on Oct 13 (differences vs. sameness, the connoisseur, the ten thousand things, the "lump of earth", still water). It was also one of the three versions of Confucius on Oct 6, and on Oct 27 Webb named it 'Portrait D', Confucius as would-be disciple.
- Chapter 5No-Toes Lectures Confucius, Who Is Fettered by HeavenAbout 27 minutes: two segments plus the Lao Dan exchange and a Q&A on fame on Oct 6, a review on Oct 13, and on Oct 27 it was Webb's 'Portrait A', the obtuse Confucius, which he contrasted directly with Shentu Jia's teacher. He insisted that you carry the reading through to the end, the conversation with Lao Dan.
- Chapter 5Ai Taituo, the Irresistibly Ugly Man: Powers Whole, Virtue FormlessWebb spent about 28 minutes on it across three lectures (Oct 6, the Oct 13 review, Oct 27). He called Confucius's "whole in power" speech 'a manifesto for Zhuangzianism', warned that reading it as 'don't judge a book by its cover' is shallow, and singled out the Ai Taituo / carpenter's oak comparison as the kind of connection he wants.
- Chapter 5Huizi Asks: Can a Man Be Without Feelings?About 24 minutes on Oct 13. Webb skipped a planned passage to reach it, then spent a long Q&A on what Zhuangzian 'distance' is: not a lobotomy, not stoicism, it includes joy and love, and 'distance' rather than 'detachment'. His Oct 27 emotions discussion (the pet analogy) reinforced it.
- Chapter 6The True Man Breathes from His HeelsThe info sheet's last question asks how "the unity of all things" figures into the True Man. Webb previewed the passage as deliberately over-the-top rhetoric and answered that question directly in the final review: the True Man is "always in the zone".
Which passage answers which topic
The ten topics from the info sheet across the top, the essay-kit passages down the side. A dot means the passage is a good way into that topic. Hover a topic to dim the passages that don't fit.
The ten topics on the info sheet
"In all cases, reference to specific passages will serve you well." For each topic: an angle to argue, and the passages to argue it with.
Topic 1
Zhuangzi is deeply skeptical of thinking in "binaries." Explain.
Opposites like this/that, useful/useless, big/small and life/death produce each other and depend on where you stand. The sage stands at the hinge, where they lose their opposites.
Topic 2
How does Zhuangzi show us that perspective places limitations on cognition?
Every creature judges from its own scale: the quail mocks the Peng, Huizi can only see a smashable gourd, Wang Ni asks how a person, an eel and a monkey could agree on the right place to live.
Topic 3
How does Zhuangzi encourage us to think about our emotions?
Keep distance: feelings arise like wind in hollows, but the sage "doesn't allow good or bad to get in and do him harm". Not numbness, and not only sorrow: joy and praise too.
- 梧 Huizi Asks: Can a Man Be Without Feelings?
- 风 The Ladder of Freedom: Song Rongzi, Liezi and the Perfect Man
- 菌 The Restless Mind and the Missing True Lord
- 冶 Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- 薪 Lao Dan's Funeral: Three Cries and the Fire Passes On
- 歌 Singing Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the Realm
Topic 4
Explain Zhuangzi's concept of uselessness.
Usefulness gets things cut down and used up; 'useless' things live out their years. And 'useful' is always useful to someone, for something.
Topic 5
Explain an episode in which a former criminal amputee is presented as spiritually enlightened.
Losing a foot marked a convicted criminal for life. Zhuangzi makes these outcasts the teachers, and the whole-bodied officials and Confucius the ones who are spiritually maimed.
Topic 6
Cook Ding's skill at butchering oxen: what is it meant to illustrate? How does it fit, or not fit, with other ideas in Zhuangzi?
Skill that becomes the Way: perception shifts from the whole ox to spirit following the heavenly pattern, so nothing wears down. It fits the fasting of the mind and 'caring for life'; it sits uneasily with Zhuangzi's suspicion of method and teaching.
Topic 7
Describe Zhuangzi's philosophy of death.
Death is one more transformation in the process of change, so neither dread nor excessive mourning fits. Not resignation: it's being "freed from the bonds of God" while still alive.
- 歌 Singing Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the Realm
- 冶 Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- 薪 Lao Dan's Funeral: Three Cries and the Fire Passes On
- 梦 Lady Li's Tears and the Great Dream
- 梦 Meng-sun Ts'ai Mourns Without Grief
- 蝶 Zhuang Zhou Dreams He Is a Butterfly
- 鱼 Fish on Dry Land and the Boat Hidden in the Ravine
Topic 8
In what sense is Zhuangzi a critique of ideas held sacred by Confucianists?
Ritual mourning, reforming rulers through benevolence and righteousness, fame and moral reputation, the junzi as the ideal person: Zhuangzi shows each as a fetter or a distortion.
Topic 9
Contrast at least two of the several versions of Confucius, as a literary character, that appear in Zhuangzi.
Obtuse (with Toeless), a respectful outsider (at the funeral singing), a Zhuangzian mentor (Yan Hui's fasting of the mind), a would-be disciple (of Wang Tai). Never 'inconsistent': each is used for a different purpose.
- 趾 No-Toes Lectures Confucius, Who Is Fettered by Heaven
- 歌 Singing Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the Realm
- 斋 Yan Hui and the Fasting of the Mind
- 兀 Wang Tai, the One-Footed Teacher, and the Still Water
- 忘 Yan Hui Sits Down and Forgets Everything
- 豚 Ai Taituo, the Irresistibly Ugly Man: Powers Whole, Virtue Formless
Topic 10
How does "the unity of all things" figure into Zhuangzi's description of the "True Man" or "Utmost Person"?
Seen from sameness, the ten thousand things are one, so the True Man doesn't cling to life, fear death, or treat gain and loss as different. His stillness comes from that view.
- 踵 The True Man Breathes from His Heels
- 兀 Wang Tai, the One-Footed Teacher, and the Still Water
- 秋豪 “There Is a Beginning…”: One, Words and Three
- 风 The Ladder of Freedom: Song Rongzi, Liezi and the Perfect Man
- 冶 Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- 蝶 Zhuang Zhou Dreams He Is a Butterfly
Gold chips have a full essay kit. The others link to the story in its chapter.
Things he warned against
- Never call Confucius "inconsistent": each appearance is a different literary Confucius used by the narrator.
- Say "distance", not "detachment", for Zhuangzi on emotions. It isn't numbness or stoicism, and it covers joy and love too.
- Zhuangzi's view of death is not resignation or fatalism, and death itself is not "the liberation".
- Don't reduce Ai Taituo to "don't judge a book by its cover". He called that shallow.
- De 德 here means power or potency, not Confucian moral virtue.
- Don't read Buddhism (karma, reincarnation) into Zhuangzi.
- The test is on Zhuangzi. Light comparison with Confucian ritual is fine; keep the focus on Zhuangzi.
- The fate-and-duty passage (the Duke of She, ch. 4) is not on the test.