Skip to content
Test 2 overview

Also likely Chapter 5, The Sign of Virtue Complete

Huizi Asks: Can a Man Be Without Feelings? 人故无情乎

About 24 minutes on Oct 13. Webb skipped a planned passage to reach it, then spent a long Q&A on what Zhuangzian 'distance' is: not a lobotomy, not stoicism, it includes joy and love, and 'distance' rather than 'detachment'. His Oct 27 emotions discussion (the pet analogy) reinforced it.

EmotionsTrue ManBinaries

The passage at a glance

Being 'without feelings' means not letting likes and dislikes harm you inside: just following what is natural and not trying to add to life.

The chapter-ending dialogue. Huizi (Hui Tzu, Hui Shi), the logician who is Zhuangzi's friend and sparring partner, attacks the claim just made about the sage, that he has "the form of a man but not the feelings of a man". Can a person without feelings still be a person? The stakes: if feelings make us human, does Zhuangzi's ideal make us less human?

  1. 1/6Huizi: 'Can a man really be without feelings?' Zhuangzi: 'Yes.'人故无情乎
  2. 2/6'Then how is he human?' 'The Way gave him a face, heaven a form.'道与之貌,天与之形
  3. 3/6'No feelings' means: don't let likes and dislikes harm you inside.不以好恶内伤其身
  4. 4/6Just follow what's natural; don't try to add to life.常因自然,而不益生也
  5. 5/6'You waste your spirit, moaning against trees, dozing on your desk.'倚树而吟,据槁梧而瞑
  6. 6/6'Heaven picked your form, and you chirp about hard and white!'天选子之形,子以坚白鸣

Close reading

Step 1 of every answer: the details, and what each one implies.

  1. Huizi: "But a man who has no feelings—how can you call him a man?"

    Huizi argues like a logician: feelings define a person, so no feelings means no person. Zhuangzi refuses the definition: "The Way gave him a face; Heaven gave him a form". Being human is something received, not something proved by having moods.

  2. No feelings means "a man doesn't allow good or bad to get in and do him harm"

    This is a redefinition, not a denial of emotion. Feelings arise, but likes and dislikes are kept from getting inside and wounding you. Webb's word was 'distance', a matter of degree, not 'detachment', which is all-or-nothing. "Good" is on the list too, so joy and love are covered.

  3. "He just lets things be the way they are and doesn't try to help life along."

    This means not forcing or managing life. Huizi's anxious follow-up, "how can he keep himself alive?", shows he assumes life must be propped up by effort. Compare the True Man of chapter 6, who does not use "man to help out Heaven".

  4. "You treat your spirit like an outsider. You wear out your energy"

    Zhuangzi turns the tables. The man who prides himself on reason is the one being harmed: his love of argument has got inside and is draining him.

  5. "leaning on a tree and moaning, slumping at your desk and dozing"

    A comic portrait of the exhausted intellectual. It echoes chapter 2, where "Hui Tzu leaned on his desk" and his school ended in the foolishness of "hard" and "white".

  6. "Heaven picked out a body for you and you use it to gibber about 'hard' and 'white'"

    In a chapter of amputees and hunchbacks, the whole-bodied logician is the one misusing what Heaven gave him. "Hard and white" was the logicians' dispute over whether attributes exist apart from things. Watson notes the jab rhymes in the original. Huizi gets no reply, and the chapter ends.

How it ends. Zhuangzi repeats his answer (the Way gave a face, Heaven a form; he doesn't let good or bad in) and closes by mocking Huizi for wearing out his spirit and using his Heaven-chosen body "to gibber about 'hard' and 'white'". Huizi doesn't reply, and chapter 5 ends there, like chapters 1 and 2, with Huizi as the foil. The exam may cut the passage short, so show you know this.

Connect it to other passages

Step 3: link by theme, image or formula, and say how the two are alike and how they differ.

formulaChapter 6Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal

"neither sorrow nor joy can touch you"

Alike
Master Yu, twisted by illness, says that if you are content with the time "neither sorrow nor joy can touch you", the same as not letting "good or bad" get in. Both lists include joy as well as sorrow.
Different
The Huizi passage defines the stance in argument. Master Yu lives it in his own failing body, peering at his reflection in a well and wondering whether his arm will become a rooster. That is distance with curiosity, not a lack of feeling.
formulaChapter 3Lao Dan's Funeral: Three Cries and the Fire Passes On

"grief and joy have no way to enter"

Alike
Qin Shi (Ch'in Shih) uses the same formula: if you are content with the time, "grief and joy have no way to enter in."
Different
Qin Shi still goes in to mourn and gives "three cries" before leaving. So 'no feelings' does not mean no expression. The sage mourns briefly. What he rejects is the excessive weeping he calls "the crime of hiding from Heaven".
imageChapter 2The Restless Mind and the Missing True Lord

emotions as "music from empty holes"

Alike
Both treat emotions as real but passing: in chapter 2 they are wind through hollows, "Let it be! Let it be!", and here good and bad are simply not let in.
Different
Chapter 2 describes ordinary minds swept along by moods with no "True Lord" in sight. The Huizi passage shows the alternative, a person the moods don't injure, and aims it at a specific person who is wearing himself out.
formulaChapter 6The True Man Breathes from His Heels

not helping life (or Heaven) along

Alike
"Doesn't try to help life along" matches the True Man, who does not use "man to help out Heaven" and "knew nothing of loving life, knew nothing of hating death".
Different
The True Man passage shows him with feelings: "his joy and anger prevail through the four seasons", and "annoyed, he let it show in his face". That proves 'no feelings' was never numbness.
themeChapter 1Huizi's Giant Gourd and the Chapped-Hands Salve

Huizi's rigid categories

Alike
Both times Huizi is trapped by a fixed definition (gourds are for dipping; people are defined by feelings), and Zhuangzi needles him for it: "You certainly are dense when it comes to using big things!"
Different
In chapter 1 the narrowness concerns usefulness and objects. Here it concerns human nature, and the jab is personal: Huizi is wasting his own body and spirit.

What he said in class

Oct 13, 46:09

Would distance from our feelings make us less human?

3 points from this part of the lecture
  • He skipped the passage he had planned on p. 71, saying the point was already covered, and moved to Hui Shi on feelings because it shows what stepping back from emotions and from the data flow of eyes and ears would actually look like.
  • The worry is that if we define our humanness by our feelings, pleasurable and awful, then disengaging from them seems to make us less human.
  • Tying back to sameness and difference: conventionally, my feelings plus my experiences make me a distinct individual. Using a student as his example, he contrasted a young undergraduate woman in 2026 with himself. If both could achieve distance from their feelings, would the distinction between them shrink?
Oct 13, 49:10

Hui Shi: 'Can a man really be without feelings?'

4 points from this part of the lecture
  • Hui Shi (Watson: Hui Tzu) was a logician, possibly a contemporary of Zhuangzi or even his mentor, and 'a bit of a logic chopper'.
  • His logic: feelings are inherent to a person, so a being without feelings would no longer be a person. Zhuangzi answers that the Way gave him a face and Heaven gave him a form, so why not call him a man?
  • Zhuangzi's redefinition: 'no feelings' means not letting good or bad get in and do you harm, letting things be as they are, and 'not trying to help life along'.
  • Zhuangzi's jab at Hui Shi: you treat your spirit like an outsider and wear out your energy leaning on a tree and moaning. Heaven picked out a body for you, and you use it to gibber about 'hard and white'. That refers to the logicians' disputes over whether whiteness or hardness exists apart from the thing, as in the 'white horse' debate. Zhuangzi saw these as frivolous, meaningless philosophising and mocks them.
Oct 13, 52:43

Off the roller coaster: Q&A on lobotomy

3 points from this part of the lecture
  • All things are in flux. Conventionally we celebrate or lament every change and ride the roller coaster of our feelings. Zhuangzi portrays someone who has 'sequestered' themselves from that ride, so that even death, the thing we all dread, is of no concern.
  • A student asked whether, on this view, a lobotomised patient would be the ideal person. The professor said no. Zhuangzi elsewhere acknowledges that people will get angry, sad and happy. The aim is not to negate feeling or become numb, but to gain distance so that feelings don't cut or harm you. You notice 'this is a transition toward sadness, and soon it will turn into something else.'
  • Preview for Thursday (Chapter 6): people with disfiguring, degenerative illnesses who, rather than lamenting their withering and curling bodies, are portrayed as reveling in the changes.
Oct 13, 57:20

Not stoicism: joy and love too

3 points from this part of the lecture
  • A student asked how this differs from Stoicism. He said he doesn't know capital-S Roman Stoicism well enough to speak to it. Lowercase 'stoic' (he checked the dictionary) means enduring pain or hardship without showing feelings or complaining, so it is about hardship. Nobody tells you to be more stoic about your joy.
  • He firmly corrected a student who thought Zhuangzi targets mainly negative emotions: it is 'the whole kit and caboodle', joy and love included.
  • Example: 'I'm so in love' is a provisional feeling that will transform into something else. Couples split up chasing that one feeling. Wisdom means rolling with it and seeing what it turns into next, instead of lamenting that it has changed.
Oct 13, 01:01:58

Distance from joy: a ballplayer's father, a Kyoto mentor, and 'distance' vs. 'detachment'

“Take a couple steps back and watch the show.”
4 points from this part of the lecture
  • Baseball example: during the Blue Jays' World Series run against the Dodgers last season, a young star (the name is garbled in the transcript; possibly Vladimir Guerrero Jr.) went wild after an early win. His father, a former big-leaguer, scolded him to tone it down because there were many games left, and the Dodgers did end up winning.
  • Personal story: while at Kyoto University he applied to US PhD programmes and was admitted in comparative literature with a five-year fellowship. His Japanese mentor (his 'Japanese dad') was thrilled but told him to be careful: avoid drinking and getting into fights, and ride his bike carefully. Great happiness is like drunkenness, an altered state in which you lose your ordinary vigilance.
  • A student summarised: feelings are inevitable, but the wise don't get carried away. The professor agreed. The aim is not to refuse attachment to avoid sadness; it is to take a couple of steps back, watch the show, and take delight in the transformations whether convention calls them positive or negative.
  • He rejects 'detach' because it is an all-or-nothing word: you're either attached or detached. 'Distance' is spatial and a matter of degree. You watch your feelings from a perch ('wow, this is exciting', 'oh, this is terrible') while they happen, but they don't affect you.

These notes are an AI summary of Zoom's automatic transcript, not checked against the recording. Speech recognition garbles names and words, so a detail can be wrong. Each segment has its timestamp: check it in the recording before relying on it.

Avoid

  • Say 'distance', not 'detachment'. Don't equate it with numbness (Webb rejected the lobotomy reading) or with stoicism, which is about enduring hardship.
  • It covers joy and love too ('the whole kit and caboodle'), not just negative emotions. "Good" is in Zhuangzi's own sentence.
  • Don't import Buddhist non-attachment. Keep it to Zhuangzi's terms: not letting likes and dislikes "get in and do him harm".

Write it

A thesis you could argue:By redefining 'no feelings' as not letting "good or bad" get in and do harm, Zhuangzi escapes Huizi's logical trap and shows that the real damage comes from the habit of judging, of liking, disliking and arguing about "hard" and "white", which Huizi mistakes for being human.

0 / ~350 words

The guidance from lecture comes from AI summaries of Zoom's auto-transcripts. The logistics and topics come from the official info sheet.

逍遥游

Study companion for COLT-382, Zen and Daoism in Asian Literature. Quotations are short excerpts from Burton Watson's translation. Lecture notes are AI summaries of Zoom's auto-transcripts, not checked against the recordings; use the timestamps to verify anything you plan to rely on.

Press ⌘K anywhere to jump to a story, term or lecture.