Lectures
Eight sessions on the Zhuangzi, from the first "assault on common sense" to the week before the test.
These notes are an AI summary of Zoom's automatic transcript, not checked against the recording. Speech recognition garbles names and words, so a detail can be wrong. Each segment has its timestamp: check it in the recording before relying on it.
- 1Tuesday, September 29
An Assault on Common Sense: Funerals, Big Birds, and the Driver Who Is Always Just Right
Opening lecture of the Zhuangzi unit, given right after the Analects test. Webb frames Zhuangzi as a purveyor of 'uncommon sense' (Japanese hijōshiki) and builds a 'commonsense' Confucian picture of a life (birth, learning hierarchy in the family, joining other hierarchies, death, funeral, mourning) so he can break it with chapter 6's story of the friends who sing beside Master Sanghu's corpse. Birth and death become neutral transformations, not a beginning and an end. After an orientation to the text (Wade-Giles vs. pinyin, Zhuangzi the person vs. the Zhuangzi the book, the 33 sections and the seven Inner Chapters), he reads the opening of chapter 1 (Kun/Peng and the laughing quail). Using a George Carlin bit about drivers, he argues that judgments of big and small are arbitrary and that the self-satisfied Confucian official is the quail.
鹏 Ch. 1化 Ch. 618 segments
- 2Thursday, October 1
Useless Gourds, an Unbothered Monk, and Cook Ding's Knife
Webb finishes chapter 1 and begins chapter 3. He reviews the 'assault on common sense' and the quail/Confucian-official link, then uses Huizi's huge gourd and the chapped-hands salve to argue that usefulness and uselessness are imposed by narrow, conventional perspectives, not inherent in things. Song Rongzi's indifference to praise and blame is illustrated with the Zen story of Hakuin and the false paternity accusation ('Is that so?'). The point is equanimity toward both condemnation and praise. The second half is a close reading of Cook Ding: virtuosity acquired in stages, perception by spirit (shen) rather than the eyes, following the 'heavenly pattern' (tianli), and analogies to being 'in the zone' in sports, music and cooking.
鹏 Ch. 1刀 Ch. 315 segments
- 3Tuesday, October 6
Broken Bodies, Whole Powers: Amputees, a Prime Minister, and the Ugliest Man in Wei
The professor opens Chapter 5 ('The Sign of Virtue Complete'), which centres on people whose bodies are unusual. He first explains why an amputee in early China was understood as a convicted repeat offender and a permanent social outcast. He then reads three linked episodes closely: Shentu Jia's rebuke of the prime minister Zichan, Confucius's failed meeting with Toeless Shushan (and Toeless's report to Lao Dan), and Duke Ai's question about the hideously ugly but magnetic Ai Taituo. Across all three, Zhuangzi turns the conventional valuation of whole and broken upside down. The physically 'broken' outsider has spiritual fullness, while the successful official or the famous moralist is the one who is crippled. The session closes on Confucius's 'manifesto' of being 'whole in power' and on the stillness of virtue that 'takes no form'.
兀 Ch. 519 segments
- 4Tuesday, October 13
Still Water and the Ten Thousand Things: Wang Tai, Hui Shi, and Feelings at a Distance
Back from fall break, the professor reviews last week's Chapter 5 episodes (Shentu Jia and Zichan, Toeless and Confucius, Ai Taituo) and draws out their common thread: Zhuangzi's social outcasts are 'on to something' that the officially wise are not. He then reads the chapter's opening story of the one-footed teacher Wang Tai. The focus is looking at things by their sameness rather than their differences ('liver and gall' vs. 'the ten thousand things are all one'), using the image of the tiresome connoisseur. He explains Wang Tai's charisma as the pull of still water. The last third of the class treats Hui Shi's question 'Can a man really be without feelings?' and, through student questions about lobotomy and Stoicism, works out that Zhuangzi asks for distance from all emotions, joy as well as grief, rather than their elimination or 'detachment'.
兀 Ch. 516 segments
- 5Thursday, October 15
Watching the Show: Sickness, Death and the Friends Beyond the Realm
A close reading of the end of chapter 6 ("The Great and Venerable Teacher"). Webb revisits the four friends (Masters Si, Yu, Li and Lai), reading Master Yu's illness and Master Lai's deathbed as models of a 'heightened sensibility of acceptance' toward transformation, with a long digression on death doulas and the smith-and-metal image as a critique of vanity about the afterlife. Students then work in groups on the three friends (Sanghu, Mengzi Fan, Qin Zhang) and Confucius's response to their funeral singing; Webb stresses that the 'Confucius' in Zhuangzi is a fabricated literary character with no unity across episodes, and unpacks 'the petty man of Heaven is the gentleman among men.' He closes on Zhuangzi's 'crisis of language,' using Wittgenstein's ladder.
化 Ch. 618 segments
- 6Tuesday, October 20
Useless Trees, Useless People, and the Fasting of the Mind
A close reading of chapter 4, "In the World of Men." Webb starts with Carpenter Shi and the useless oak at the shrine and with Cripple Shu, framing usefulness as dangerous in an age of wars, conscription and corvée labor. A pair exercise asks for modern cases where uselessness helps you survive (credit cards, planned obsolescence, weaponized ignorance), which leads into an argument that useful and useless only exist relative to each other and are arbitrary consensus. A tangent on 'this' and 'that' across languages (English two-tier, Japanese three-tier) links back to chapter 2's attack on distinctions. The last 20 minutes cover Yan Hui's plan to reform the ruler of Wei, where Confucius rejects every strategy and teaches the 'fasting of the mind.'
栎 Ch. 4蝶 Ch. 219 segments
- 7Thursday, October 22
The Tour de Force Soliloquy: Making All Things Equal
The last lecture on new Zhuangzi material is a close reading of Chapter 2, 'Discussion on Making All Things Equal' (Qiwulun 齐物论). Webb deliberately saved it for the end because it sums up nearly every issue raised so far. He works from Ziqi of South Wall 'losing himself' and the three kinds of piping, through emotions as wind in the body's hollows, the arbitrariness of language and the Confucian–Mohist 'war of words', 'this and that' and the hinge of the Way, 'three in the morning', and 'the Great Way is not named', ending with the butterfly dream. His central point is that Zhuangzi walks us out of dichotomies, value judgments and trust in language without handing us a new blueprint. At its highest, the 'Way' is the way that is not a way. He opened by moving the midterm to Thursday 10/29 and describing its new passage-analysis format.
蝶 Ch. 219 segments
- 8Tuesday, October 27
Bonus Review: Many Confuciuses, Broken Binaries, and the Shelf Life of Feelings
This was a student-driven review session for the Zhuangzi midterm on Thursday 10/29; no new material was introduced. Webb first set out the exam: 4 passages, choose 3, each a 'mini-essay' combining close reading with connections to other episodes. He then worked through questions from his posted study guide. Topics included the several contradictory portraits of Confucius in the text and why they need not be consistent, and Zhuangzi's critique of binaries (big/small, right/wrong, gentleman/petty man, useful/useless, life/death). He also distinguished the virtuoso's momentary glimpse of unity from the true person who dwells there. The last stretch covered Zhuangzi's philosophy of death and emotion, using Lady Li, the 'lost child', a pet-owner analogy, and modern riddles about medicine and YOLO, and ended with Zhuangzi's critiques of Confucianism and how fate and duty keep one foot in the world.
鹏 Ch. 1蝶 Ch. 2刀 Ch. 3栎 Ch. 4兀 Ch. 5化 Ch. 618 segments