Tuesday, October 27, lecture 8 of 8
Bonus Review: Many Confuciuses, Broken Binaries, and the Shelf Life of Feelings
This was a student-driven review session for the Zhuangzi midterm on Thursday 10/29; no new material was introduced. Webb first set out the exam: 4 passages, choose 3, each a 'mini-essay' combining close reading with connections to other episodes. He then worked through questions from his posted study guide. Topics included the several contradictory portraits of Confucius in the text and why they need not be consistent, and Zhuangzi's critique of binaries (big/small, right/wrong, gentleman/petty man, useful/useless, life/death). He also distinguished the virtuoso's momentary glimpse of unity from the true person who dwells there. The last stretch covered Zhuangzi's philosophy of death and emotion, using Lady Li, the 'lost child', a pet-owner analogy, and modern riddles about medicine and YOLO, and ended with Zhuangzi's critiques of Confucianism and how fate and duty keep one foot in the world.
鹏1. Free and Easy Wandering蝶2. Discussion on Making All Things Equal刀3. The Secret of Caring for Life栎4. In the World of Men兀5. The Sign of Virtue Complete化6. The Great and Venerable Teacher
These notes are an AI summary of Zoom's automatic transcript, not checked against the recording. Speech recognition garbles names and words, so a detail can be wrong. Each segment has its timestamp: check it in the recording before relying on it.
- 00:07
Exam format: 4 passages, write on 3
- He confirmed the format: four passages, from which you choose three to write on.
- Component 1, close reading: attend to the details and nuances of the text, such as the relations between the people and the implications of what happens (e.g. in the Cook Ding story). No plot summary or regurgitation, since he has already read it. Test: could you explain the passage's significance to someone who has never taken the class?
- Component 2, connections: link the passage's themes, images or formulas to other things in the Zhuangzi, either thematically (here's someone 'in the zone'; who else is? what does that mean for the utmost person?) or by image or formula (an amputee here, compared with another amputee: alike how, different how, and what is Zhuangzi telling us?).
- There are no targeted sub-questions, only a general preamble saying the analysis should include these things. 'It's you and the text.' The best answers do both: the small-bore focus and the big-picture significance.
- For long passages he may excerpt only the salient part. Show that you know what goes on and how the story ends.
- 04:29
Length, no 'Form B', study sheets and the study guide
- On length, he floated about 350 and possibly up to 500 words per answer. If you cover what he described you'll naturally reach 300–350, longer than a 200–250-word short answer. He asked students not to waste time counting words while handwriting.
- A student asked for an alternate 8-short-question version. He refused: 'three mini-essays... now is the time to spread your wings.' On the Confucius test he 'had to hold you tight'. This format prepares you for the final.
- He praised the first-exam study sheets ('dazzled'), some thematic and some going passage by passage (1.1, 1.2...), and returned them with the tests. Keep them for the final. All his feedback was sent by email, not written in the bluebooks.
- Study sheet rules are unchanged: one side of an 8.5x11 sheet.
- He posted a study guide (also as a Word document) over the weekend: 'topics to consider... by no means comprehensive... a departure point for your review. In all cases, reference to specific passages will serve you well.' In other words, attach themes to concrete passages.
- 12:42
Portraits of Confucius, A: the obtuse Confucius (Toeless Shushan)
Chapter 5No-Toes Lectures Confucius, Who Is Fettered by Heaven
- A study-guide question asks you to contrast 'at least two' portraits of Confucius. In section they found at least four.
- Portrait A: Toeless Shushan visits Confucius, who scolds him. Webb said you must carry the reading through to the end of the anecdote, where Toeless goes to Lao Dan (Lao Tzu) and they discuss Confucius as someone who has missed the boat: 'what should we do for him?' Now they are the ones talking down about him.
- This is one episode with two components: Confucius as a speaking character, then as the topic of other characters' conversation. The portrait is consistent across both. He is 'a dingbat'.
- A third component: Confucius tells his students, 'Look how hard Toeless is trying; you have both feet, so try even harder.' That is 'just about the last lesson' a Zhuangzian mind would draw. Webb's word for this Confucius is obtuse: he doesn't get it.
- 17:16
Portrait B: Confucius who recognizes those beyond the realm
Chapter 6Singing Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the Realm
- Zigong comes back from the friends' funeral (where they were singing by the corpse) scandalized. Confucius says it was his mistake to send him: they operate on a totally different logic. They wander beyond the realm, while 'men like me wander within it'.
- This is a recognition of others, whether or not it amounts to admiration, 'maybe begrudging'.
- The caricature of Confucians is that their way is the path, so anyone off it is a deviant to be saved, and there is an element of righteousness in that. Here Confucius shows a flexibility we don't always see: 'They're not deviants we have to save; they just do their own thing.'
- 18:43
Portrait C: Confucius as Zhuangzian mentor, and why the portraits needn't be consistent
Chapter 4Yan Hui and the Fasting of the Mind
- Other portraits include Confucius who merely acknowledges such people, Confucius who wants to become a follower himself, and Confucius as a full Zhuangzian mentor.
- Mentor: Yan Hui (Yen Hui) wants to go reform the ruler of Wei. That is exactly what the Confucius of Unit 1 would encourage: go teach them, just don't get co-opted. Here Confucius shuts down every plan ('you'll just get yourself executed') and culminates in the fasting of the mind (心斋), going past your mind. That sounds Zhuangzian, not Confucian, coming from Confucius' mouth.
- A student asked whether Confucius is being inconsistent or doesn't know which way is right. Webb said 'don't go there'. Assuming a named character is the same across a book is how we read fiction (Harry Potter grows but is always Harry Potter), and it doesn't apply here.
- Each Confucius is a different Confucius, deployed by whoever is orchestrating the narrative. Don't expect consistency, and don't write that he is contradicting himself.
“It is a Confucius, yes, but it is a different Confucius. Don't expect it to be consistent.”
- 21:34
Portrait D: Confucius as aspirant (Wang Tai, Duke Ai)
Chapter 5Wang Tai, the One-Footed Teacher, and the Still WaterAi Taituo, the Irresistibly Ugly Man: Powers Whole, Virtue Formless
- A student described the Confucius who isn't a mentor but an aspirant. We don't see him become a disciple, but we hear him wishing it.
- This is the Wang Tai episode. The one-footed Wang Tai has as many followers in Lu as Confucius, and Confucius says he will go to him as his teacher and 'bring the whole world along' to follow him. Webb said a similar line of thinking appears in Duke Ai and Confucius' conversation about the ugly man Ai Taituo.
- Asked whether the fasting-of-the-mind passage is 'Confucius as aspirant', Webb said no. That is Confucius as Zhuangzian mentor, because there he is almost mimicking Zhuangzian ideology in what he negates.
- 24:22
The critique of binaries: Peng, the little creatures, and perspectivalism
Chapter 1The Fish That Became a BirdThe Cicada, the Dove and the Quail Laugh
- A student's answer: the small creatures laugh at the enormous Peng bird because they can't comprehend its size. The binary being critiqued is big vs. small, and comparisons are arbitrary because they are relative.
- Chapter 1 is where the text starts throwing out binaries and perspectivalism. What you think is big or little depends on your position. More deeply, even grammatically, big and little exist only in definition of each other.
- You can't say 'that's a big tree' without someone asking 'big compared to what?' We can only agree it's big because we already agree on what's small. You could call it relativism.
- Zhuangzi's claim: whenever we make sense of the world we lazily rely on binaries. That's all we do, inside and outside ourselves.
- The binaries escalate from the commonsensical (high/low flying, speedy, longevity) to the abstract: success/failure, fame/disgrace, and most importantly life/death. All are temporary constructs of our minds rather than inherent facts, and they dissolve when viewed in longer terms.
- 29:16
Right and wrong: who can judge the debate?
Chapter 2Who Can Judge the Debate?
- Asked whether there is no good and evil, Webb noted that 'good and evil' is hard to discuss outside a Christian milieu. Zhuangzi certainly says right and wrong are quite arbitrary.
- His example: two people disagree and call in a third to mediate. If the mediator likes one party better, she'll favor that argument, which doesn't make anything right, just another person saying something.
- Call in a fourth to check the third's objectivity, and that person has their own interests. It goes on and on.
- Conclusion: right and wrong can't be decided with certainty, only provisionally and temporarily.
- 30:36
Amputees and ex-criminals as the spiritually whole; flipping gentleman and petty man
Chapter 6Shentu Jia and the Prime Minister: A Mirror Without DustAi Taituo, the Irresistibly Ugly Man: Powers Whole, Virtue FormlessSinging Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the Realm
- Asked about a former criminal or amputee presented as enlightened: the Prime Minister (Zichan) and the amputee Shentu Jia fits. Other amputees are regarded as charismatic because they have a spiritual something other people lack. Webb agreed it connects to Ai Taituo, since both are marginal figures.
- 'The petty man of Heaven is the gentleman among men; the gentleman among men is the petty man of Heaven': Zhuangzi toys with the dichotomy and flips it. You thought these were hard-and-fast definitions, but change perspective and you can invert them. That shows how meaningless the dichotomies are.
- Summary: the binaries that dictate our lives are relative and shaped by our position, so they are limitations Zhuangzi wants to break us out of.
- Anticipated objection: why keep talking about the Way, or being 'in the zone'? Isn't that a dichotomy too? Zhuangzi anticipates this and says yes. At the beginner level he dissolves big/little, then moves to philosophical dichotomies, and at the highest level: 'there is no way!' Talking about a Way implies a not-way, which is exactly the habit of mind he's trying to cure.
- 'This and that' (Ch. 2) is good to invoke if you understand it, but it's not required. There are other ways to get at the interrogation of dichotomies.
- Useful/useless is absolutely a binary, and he flips it: what you thought useless is useful, like the huge tree that shades a thousand teams of horses.
- 38:20
Is the carpenter's oak charismatic like Ai Taituo?
Chapter 4Carpenter Shi and the Shrine OakAi Taituo, the Irresistibly Ugly Man: Powers Whole, Virtue Formless
- A student asked whether the shrine oak has a spiritual wholeness like Ai Taituo's. Webb called it an interesting parallel.
- Conventionally the tree holds no attraction whatsoever for a carpenter ('cut it, sap comes out, we'd poison ourselves'), yet it has grown up with a charismatic presence, just as the ugly Ai Taituo draws people to him.
- This is the kind of cross-episode connection he wants in exam answers.
- 39:11
The true person and the unity of all things: glimpse vs. dwelling
Chapter 6The True Man Breathes from His HeelsCook Ding Carves the Ox
- On the study guide's last question (the true man and the unity of things), a student said the true man 'believes in' the unity of all things. Webb said it's stronger than belief and not a matter of faith. The utmost person actually apprehends, or sees, the unity of things and so melds in with it.
- Cook Ding and other virtuosos show that while executing their craft they are transported: no longer seeing with eyes or hearing with ears, just going with it. Zhuangzi uses such examples because ordinary readers can grasp them.
- The difference is that the virtuoso gets a glimpse of unity by losing himself in it. He says 'glimpse' to stress its momentary nature. The utmost or true person is there all the time: always in the zone.
- Taken to its end: the true person is always in the zone because he knows there is no such thing as the zone. It sounds paradoxical, 'but that's where he would land'.
- We can only talk about this in spatial metaphors (transported, resides there), which shows how hard it is to express.
“He is always in the zone. Why? Because he knows there's no such thing as the zone.”
- 43:43
Philosophy of death: a lifespan as one transformation among many
Chapter 6Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- Death is much less traumatic than people think, and birth is not the momentous beginning we take it to be. Both are natural, neutral transformations rather than things to dread or lament.
- Life/death feels like a dichotomy, and so does beginning/end. Zhuangzi asks us to change our perspective on a lifespan. The life we know is one result of an infinite series of transformations: here temporarily, then on to another transformation.
- So we shouldn't have strong feelings about either. What we call a beginning or an end is simply the next transformation. Life is not the beginning-to-finish story we 'continually, uncritically narrate to ourselves', just a neutral series of transformations.
- He would 'not be surprised if, in some way or another, you would have to write about death in the exam'.
- 47:14
Lady Li and the lost child
Chapter 2Lady Li's Tears and the Great Dream
- Lady Li dreaded being given as wife to a ruler in a far-off land and wept at leaving her family. Once there, she shared his bed, ate fine food, and had a happy life. This is the same pattern as death: anxiety builds up to the day, the transformation happens, and it's not so bad after all.
- The same passage asks: what if, in dreading death, we are like a child who left home young and forgot the way back, and dying is coming home? If you can keep your mind around that, you needn't fret so much.
- Zhuangzi talks about these things by implication, through metaphors and anecdotes, because that is easiest for us to understand.
- These are good to have 'in your back pocket', but he doesn't think he'll ask about these particular ones. The exam passages will be longer anecdotes.
- 49:22
Rituals, emotions, and stepping back to watch the show (the pet analogy)
Chapter 2The Restless Mind and the Missing True Lord
- Should there be no celebration of birth or mourning of death? There are no stories of Zhuangzi crashing birthday parties. Funerals are what really bother him. But his critique implies that birth as a beginning is fallacious, just a story we tell ourselves, so why make such a show of it?
- On emotions: the text gives encyclopedic lists (grief, anger, joy, envy...). He is not saying emotions are bad and should be eliminated. He is saying 'take three steps back and watch the show': the wind blowing through, sometimes joyous, sometimes grievous, sometimes infuriating. Clinging to every emotion causes misery over so much you can't control.
- Pet analogy: when a childhood pet dies, people grieve seriously. Afterwards some get another, some swear off pets, and a third way is to love the new dog while knowing in the back of your heart that its lifespan runs from here to here.
- Apply that 'veteran pet owner' stance to all feelings: each has a lifespan, maybe one afternoon, maybe 6–8 months, and there will come a time when it's done.
- Our culture says only the bad feelings are temporary ('you'll get through this'). Zhuangzi says everything is temporary, including great happiness. Rather than getting sad that it has a shelf life, step back and say 'very cool'.
- 57:23
Death as a natural process: modern medicine and YOLO
- A student framed death as a natural process. Webb agreed: anyone fighting the natural process is doing something unnatural and, in Zhuangzi's view, unnecessary.
- Open riddle: how would Zhuangzi reconcile himself to modern medicine? If heart surgery gives you 30 more years, are you affirming the allotment of life you were given, or meddling with it and 'cheating' by stretching it out? 'Hard to say', a Zhuangzian riddle about modern society.
- A student asked about YOLO / carpe diem: cramming in new experiences before death. Webb said it depends what YOLO means to you. Doing five activities in your last seven days assumes your life isn't already full. Think about the full/empty dichotomy: maybe you already have the fullness and just aren't cognizant of it.
- Finally starting German, Zhuangzi probably wouldn't hold against you. Thrill-seeking risk like skydiving or ziplining is another matter.
- There are many gaps when applying Zhuangzi to real life. Later commentators try to fill them.
- 01:02:20
What Zhuangzi critiques in Confucianism; the kind teacher vs. the rude Confucius
Chapter 5Shentu Jia and the Prime Minister: A Mirror Without DustNo-Toes Lectures Confucius, Who Is Fettered by Heaven
- Critiques to know: (1) fixation on right and wrong ('people who fixate on right and wrong typically fixate on themselves being right'); (2) the meaning of death; (3) the Confucian fixation on proper ritual. Do rituals have real significance, or are they rules you know best so you can scold others and keep them in place?
- Good contrast to know between two separate but thematically related anecdotes. In 5-shentu-jia, the teacher whose classroom holds both the Prime Minister and the amputee Shentu Jia has, in nineteen years, never once mentioned that he is missing a foot, because it is inconsequential.
- In the next episode Confucius' first words to Toeless are judgmental ('you got yourself into trouble... too late now'), and he doesn't let him speak. Within the Zhuangzi, treating someone like that is viewed negatively.
- 01:05:44
Hierarchy, fate and duty: keeping one foot in the world
Chapter 4The Duke of She's Ice Water: Fate, Duty and Riding Along with ThingsYan Hui and the Fasting of the Mind
- Recall Analects 3.19 from the first test: the reciprocity of hierarchies, with energy circulating up and down so everybody benefits. Would Zhuangzi throw social hierarchy out the window? Top/bottom and order/chaos are more dichotomies he might object to.
- However, 'In the World of Men' (Ch. 4) still insists you not abandon your parents. Confucius there says there are two great decrees, fate (a son loving his parents, which cannot be erased from his heart) and duty (a subject serving his ruler, which cannot be escaped between heaven and earth).
- The open question: as Zhuangzi pictures a spiritual evolution that dissolves all dichotomies into the unity of things, how does one keep one foot in this world? Not by becoming a mystic in the mountains, but by functioning in society and not neglecting imperative duties like caring for your parents.
- He promised to return to the footprint metaphor ('walk without touching the ground') next time. He said this fate/duty material 'is not going to be on the test'.
- 01:08:21
Extra credit and an online review session
- There will be an extra-credit question for anyone with 5–10 minutes left at the end. He told the other section it would be 'What is the way of no way?' but may substitute another one he thought up.
- An optional online review session was set for Wednesday at 8:30 pm and will be recorded.
- Graded exams were handed back, and he asked individual students with scheduling conflicts or other issues to see him after class.