Thursday, October 15, lecture 5 of 8
Watching the Show: Sickness, Death and the Friends Beyond the Realm
A close reading of the end of chapter 6 ("The Great and Venerable Teacher"). Webb revisits the four friends (Masters Si, Yu, Li and Lai), reading Master Yu's illness and Master Lai's deathbed as models of a 'heightened sensibility of acceptance' toward transformation, with a long digression on death doulas and the smith-and-metal image as a critique of vanity about the afterlife. Students then work in groups on the three friends (Sanghu, Mengzi Fan, Qin Zhang) and Confucius's response to their funeral singing; Webb stresses that the 'Confucius' in Zhuangzi is a fabricated literary character with no unity across episodes, and unpacks 'the petty man of Heaven is the gentleman among men.' He closes on Zhuangzi's 'crisis of language,' using Wittgenstein's ladder.
化6. The Great and Venerable Teacher
These notes are an AI summary of Zoom's automatic transcript, not checked against the recording. Speech recognition garbles names and words, so a detail can be wrong. Each segment has its timestamp: check it in the recording before relying on it.
- 00:39
Recap: who has access to the 'mystical realm'?
Chapter 6Cook Ding Carves the OxFour Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- Zhuangzi keeps showing us people who seem to access a 'mystical realm' that gives both comfort and an extraordinarily broad perspective on life and death.
- Three types of figure so far: the virtuoso craftsman (Cook Ding's 'dance' as he carves the ox); amputees whom conventional wisdom says should be suffering or ashamed (mutilated as punishment for crimes); and, near the end of chapter 6, people at the end of their lives with what we would call a terminal illness.
- He admits he tries to 'diagnose' the bodily changes described (maybe Parkinson's), but says that isn't the point. Like the amputees, these people are not bothered by the transformation of their bodies. They're nonchalant, even celebratory: 'What's the Creator going to do with my body next?'
- Contrast with the typical response to failing health, in ancient China and today: lament, regret ('I wish I had done this when I was healthier'), self-pity. Zhuangzi points to another attitude, another sensibility.
- 05:58
The four friends: camaraderie through a shared sensibility (p. 80)
Chapter 6Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- He revisits an anecdote from this cluster already discussed, doing a 'tight textual analysis' so the class can apply the method to other passages.
- Opening: whoever can see nonbeing as the head, life as the back and death as the rump, and knows that life and death, existence and annihilation are a single body, 'I will be his friend.' They don't distinguish life from death, and they joke about it flippantly (head, back, butt).
- What matters is the like-mindedness: people who have 'found each other' through a sensibility that is an alternative to common sense. 'Zhuangzi doesn't do common sense. Zhuangzi pushes against common sense.'
- Common sense would say these are dear friends, so when one falls ill or dies the group will grieve. The text is about to show that it's quite different.
“Zhuangzi doesn't do common sense. Zhuangzi pushes against common sense.”
- 09:34
Master Yu's illness: stepping back and watching the show
Chapter 6Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- Master Yu is badly deformed by illness (chin in his navel, shoulders above his head) and says it's amazing, not 'I'm a shadow of my former self.' For him the transformation, like life to death and death to life, is neutral.
- It goes deeper than being a 'good sport'. Yu is not only untroubled but steps back and watches the show. What we would call a medical emergency to be treated, fixed or alleviated, he simply observes and comments on.
- He goes to a well (the equivalent of a mirror), looks at his reflection and says, in effect, 'Wow, look what's happening to me. Interesting.'
- Master Si asks the question anyone would ask: 'Do you resent it?' Webb suggests Si probably already knows the answer, but it's one thing to hold the view in theory and another to have it happen to you.
“He's taking a step back and just watching the show.”
- 12:03
Rooster, crossbow pellet, cartwheels: acceptance without nostalgia
Chapter 6Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- Yu's reply (his left arm becomes a rooster to keep watch on the night, his right arm a crossbow pellet to shoot down an owl, his buttocks cartwheels with his spirit as the horse) reads almost like a game. He seems to be having fun with the contortions of his body.
- The 'Creator' (capital C) must not be mistaken for a monotheistic God figure. You can call it fate, you can call it Heaven.
- A student read the last line ('what need will I have for a carriage?') as savoring things one last time. Webb says no: it is 'flat', totally free of regret and lament. He wouldn't call it satire; it's a 'heightened sensibility of acceptance.'
- Within the provisional birth-to-death segment, everything is transformation and nothing stays still. Sitting around saying 'remember the good old days' (nostalgia for your 20s) is going against fate.
- 14:25
'Freeing of the bound': neither sorrow nor joy can touch you
Chapter 6Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- Yu: 'I received life because the time had come; I will lose it because the order of things passes on. Be content with this time and dwell in this order, and then neither sorrow nor joy can touch you.' The ancients called this 'the freeing of the bound.'
- Don't read Zhuangzi as offering an escape from bad feelings so you feel better. He puts conventionally 'negative' feelings (sadness, anger, bitterness) and 'positive' ones (relief, joy, exuberance, delight) into one category and takes a step or two back from all of it.
- Swimmer analogy from discussion section: cast into the ocean, you either exhaust yourself fighting waves far bigger than you, or you ride the energy of the wave. Survival depends on discernment, on seeing where the energy is going.
- Said abstractly: 'nothing can ever win against Heaven, that's the way it's always been. So what would I have to resent?'
- 17:42
Is this just a philosophy of resignation?
Chapter 6Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- Open question for later: if everything is fated, why bother? Whether I succeed or fail, isn't it predetermined? Some readers draw that conclusion.
- Webb's answer: no. However active you are and however much you celebrate your autonomy, there will be things in your life you can't change, some good and some bad.
- Learning to recognize 'I can't change this person / this system' is valuable because you can then direct your energies accordingly. This is discernment, not passivity.
- 19:11
Master Lai's deathbed: 'Shoo! Don't disturb the process of change'
Chapter 6Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- Master Lai is dying; his wife and children gather around weeping. Master Li arrives and tells them, 'Shoo! Get back! Don't disturb the process of change!'
- Asked why Li is so rude to the family, a student answered that they shouldn't get in the way of a process that will happen anyway. Webb agreed: don't be an impediment, and don't be so upset at what is a normal transformation of Heaven.
- You can have your feelings toward the person, but begging 'stay longer with us' is not necessarily a good thing.
- 21:12
Digression: deathbed hand-holding and death doulas
Chapter 6Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- Modern debate: should you stay at the bedside holding a dying parent's hand? One side says physical affection is communication when words are no longer possible, comforting to the dying and to those about to grieve.
- The other side, which some death doulas take (by analogy with birth doulas, they coach the dying person and family through death), says don't hold their hand or keep hugging them. Something is happening to their body; let it happen.
- Anecdotes: the person 'hangs on' and dies the moment the family steps out to the bathroom, as if saying 'leave me alone so I can get on with this.'
- There's no absolute right answer, but when veteran practitioners who have seen this hundreds of times notice commonalities, take them seriously. A hospice nurse who said 'get back' would be fired, yet Master Li's 'shoo' is not totally unusual in substance: what does the dying person actually need?
- 25:23
Rat's liver or bug's arm: what do we transform into?
Chapter 6Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- Li leans on the doorway: 'How marvelous the Creator is! What will he make of you next? Will he make you into a rat's liver? A bug's arm?'
- Callback to the simplistic timeline he drew on the board at the start of the unit: the line runs all the way around the classroom, and life and death are only a small segment of it. What comes after the transformation?
- Not reincarnation as popularly imagined (everyone claims they were Napoleon). You aren't even guaranteed to become another person: you could be a rock or an insect's leg, and 'who cares?' The transformations simply move on, endlessly.
- Key caution: don't assume an unchanging soul that crosses the thresholds of life and death and just takes on a different form. Things get mixed up and turned into something else.
- 28:45
The smith and the metal: wanting to be a famous sword is vanity
Chapter 6Four Friends, the Great Clod, and the Smith’s Leaping Metal
- Lai: a child obeys its parents and goes wherever it's told; yin and yang are more to a man than father and mother. 'The Great Clod burdens me with form, labors me with life, eases me in old age, and rests me in death. So if I think well of my life, for the same reason I must think well of my death.'
- To have any opinion, expectation or hope about what he'll become next would be 'audacious', 'forward', 'brazen', speaking out of turn.
- The blacksmith-shop metaphor: molten metal that leaps up and says 'I insist on being made into a Moye!' Famous swords were given names for their success in battle or the way they held an edge, so a named sword is an acclaimed sword.
- Hoping to become something particular after death, especially another person, is prideful vanity: 'don't bother making me unless you make me famous.' The Zhuangzian outlook is trying to expel exactly that. Heaven and earth are a great furnace, the Creator a skilled smith, and Lai can 'go off to sleep peacefully.'
- 33:16
Group exercise: re-reading the three friends with better-informed eyes (pp. 82–84)
Chapter 6Singing Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the Realm
- 'I'm trying to equip you to do your own analyses so you don't have to listen to me sermonize.' The class re-reads the Sanghu / Mengzi Fan / Qin Zhang passage, the first anecdote they studied when the Zhuangzi unit began, now with 'better-informed eyes.'
- Task, in pairs or threes: read the page and a half (about 5 minutes), then discuss its salient features and how you would explain the passage to someone outside the class (about 5 minutes).
- 46:33
How to analyze a passage: three components
Chapter 6Singing Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the Realm
- A good analysis has three parts: (1) command of the details of the passage itself; (2) an analytical effort to make sense of them; (3) a conclusion that ties those concepts to larger themes, the larger 'Zhuangzi project.'
- Imagined audience: someone curious and sympathetic who doesn't know much about ancient China or Zhuangzi.
- Start with the scene: Confucius sends Zigong to help with the funeral of Sanghu, and he finds the friends playing music and singing over the corpse instead of mourning. A student also noted that Zigong (the disciple) is baffled by this.
- 50:30
'Who can join with others without joining with others?'
Chapter 6Singing Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the Realm
- He sends the class back to the opening paragraph, which groups that jumped straight to the funeral scene skipped.
- A student compared it to the idea that life partners should support you without your leaning on them, like two trees whose roots intermingle but which each stand on their own. Webb found this a helpful way into the paradox.
- His reading: an affiliation that looks like friendship but has no strong attachment or reliance, yet still has depth of understanding. They are kindred spirits with unique sensibilities, not in a heavy emotional relationship ('I'm so disappointed because they didn't...').
- Webb first suggested the 'singular man' later in the passage is Zhuangzi's ideal (the perfect or utmost man), not Confucius referring to himself, and deferred the details (see below).
- 54:26
Confucius as a character: no 'unity of character'
Chapter 6Singing Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the Realm
- Confucius appears as a character at least four or five times in the Inner Chapters. In novels we assume a recurring name means the same, continuous person (literary scholars call this 'unity of character'). Don't make that assumption here: each appearance is a fabricated literary character carrying the name Confucius, which brings certain associations for contemporary readers.
- Here Confucius is not shown as 'I just don't get this Zhuangzian thing.' He says, in effect, 'they wander beyond the realm, I wander within it; it was stupid of me to send you to offer condolences.' It's a parallel sensibility (we have our way, they have theirs), and he is portrayed as capable of self-criticism and reflection.
- 'I am one of those punished by Heaven': asked what this means, a student said he is bound by the norms, while those men are free. Webb agreed.
- Speaking as the fictional Confucius: he can only conceive of death as finality, and that finality has social implications. People must come to the family to express condolences, indebtedness and loyalty as a new patriarch takes the place of the dead one, and the social system needs this. 'I see the charm, I see the appeal of the Zhuangzian way. I just can't do it that way.'
- 59:52
'Life as a swelling tumor': liberation is a conception, not an event
Chapter 6Singing Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the Realm
- Text: they look on life as a swelling tumor or protruding wen, and on death as the draining of a sore or the bursting of a boil. A student read this as 'they see death as freeing.'
- Webb: 'Yes and no.' Death itself is not the liberation. Holding the proper conception of death during one's lifetime is what liberates. 'You don't have to wait till you die to be liberated.'
- Emancipation and freedom are celebrated throughout Zhuangzi, but don't pinpoint death as a pivotal moment: it's just another transformation, no more momentous than drinking water or popping a pimple in the mirror.
- A student argued that 'why should they fret about the ceremonies of the vulgar world' is the strongest framing of Confucian ritual as anthropocentric or ethnocentric, versus a Zhuangzian way that looks beyond the human. Webb agreed for this passage, but other appearances of Confucius will differ.
“You don't have to wait till you die to be liberated.”
- 01:02:08
The 'singular man' and 'the petty man of Heaven is the gentleman among men'
Chapter 6Singing Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the Realm
- A student pointed out that the original word for 'singular man' (jiren 畸人) means an odd or different man: different from other men but a companion of Heaven. Here Heaven is not the Confucian Heaven but closer to the Dao, the state Cook Ding enters while carving. Webb accepted this.
- Key line (p. 84): 'The petty man of Heaven is a gentleman among men; the gentleman among men is the petty man of Heaven.' 'Petty man' is xiaoren 小人, which from the Analects we know almost never has a positive connotation (small-minded, petty); its opposite is the junzi 君子.
- Zhuangzi is playing logic games: you can be a 'big person' on this planet and amount to nothing in the eyes of Heaven, and vice versa. Choosing the Confucian path means binding yourself to an anthropocentric social morality and its politics.
- 'The best thing about Zhuangzi is that sometimes he can turn your mind into a pretzel.'
- 01:05:18
Is it transmittable? Zhuangzi's crisis of language
Chapter 6The True Man Breathes from His Heels
- Could you get these ideas across at your Thanksgiving table? The 'big picture of Zhuangzi-ism' should be filling in by now, even if parts are still 'wait, what?'
- Coming up (probably Tuesday): what he calls Zhuangzi's crisis of language. Zhuangzi is trying to convey something extremely important that goes beyond words, so he uses shortcuts and examples (the craftsmen, the amputees, the good-natured ill) to point toward what can't be expressed.
- One more round of this at the start of chapter 6, which they haven't covered: the True Man (zhenren; also translated perfect man, utmost man). The rhetoric is 'crazy' and over the top (goes into water without drowning, through fire without getting burnt) and must not be taken literally. Ask what he is trying to get across.
- 01:08:03
Wittgenstein's ladder
Chapter 6Singing Beside the Corpse: Beyond and Within the Realm
- Zhuangzi is extremely articulate, yet in places he effectively says 'I can't get it across.'
- Wittgenstein's Tractatus: you use a ladder to climb to the roof, and once you're up you don't keep walking around with it on your back. That would be preposterous.
- For Zhuangzi, as for Wittgenstein, language is the ladder when we talk about the mystical realm. Once you're up there you stop speaking of it, because words can't capture or replicate what you're experiencing.
- That's why the like-minded friends speak in riddles and then just look at each other and smile: they know, and it's inexplicable. 'Put your seatbelts on' for the over-the-top descriptions to come.
“When we're talking about the mystical realm, language is your ladder.”