Tuesday, October 20, lecture 6 of 8
Useless Trees, Useless People, and the Fasting of the Mind
A close reading of chapter 4, "In the World of Men." Webb starts with Carpenter Shi and the useless oak at the shrine and with Cripple Shu, framing usefulness as dangerous in an age of wars, conscription and corvée labor. A pair exercise asks for modern cases where uselessness helps you survive (credit cards, planned obsolescence, weaponized ignorance), which leads into an argument that useful and useless only exist relative to each other and are arbitrary consensus. A tangent on 'this' and 'that' across languages (English two-tier, Japanese three-tier) links back to chapter 2's attack on distinctions. The last 20 minutes cover Yan Hui's plan to reform the ruler of Wei, where Confucius rejects every strategy and teaches the 'fasting of the mind.'
栎4. In the World of Men蝶2. Discussion on Making All Things Equal
These notes are an AI summary of Zoom's automatic transcript, not checked against the recording. Speech recognition garbles names and words, so a detail can be wrong. Each segment has its timestamp: check it in the recording before relying on it.
- 01:38
Setting up chapter 4: close reading before the big picture
- There is a bit more Zhuangzi to cover before 'drawing a circle around everything' and drawing conclusions about Zhuangzi, and later comparing Confucianism with Zhuangzi.
- He defends the close-reading method even if it feels monotonous: attentive reading is the key to understanding Zhuangzi and the basis for extrapolating to big-picture issues.
- Today: selected episodes from chapter 4, 'In the World of Men.'
- 02:30
Carpenter Shi passes the giant oak (p. 59)
Chapter 4Carpenter Shi and the Shrine Oak
- He calls it a 'multifaceted' anecdote: the tree's voice comes through the carpenter's dream, with cross-dialogue between carpenter and apprentice and between carpenter and tree.
- The oak's exaggerated size (big enough to shade several thousand oxen) is hyperbole that should remind you of the giant Kun fish and Peng bird of chapter 1.
- A disconnect of sensibilities: the master carpenter walks right past without a glance, which puzzles the apprentice. How can we pass up a resource of this size?
- The carpenter's explanation: it's worthless timber. Boats made from it would sink, coffins would rot, it oozes sap, there's nothing it can be used for, 'that's how it got to be so old.' Even the carpenter sees that the tree's uselessness is the secret of its longevity.
“Within the tree's uselessness lies the secret of its longevity.”
- 07:20
Useful things get used, and being used shortens life
Chapter 4Carpenter Shi and the Shrine Oak
- Put the other way round, Zhuangzi would have us believe that things which are useful, or present themselves as useful, invariably get used.
- Getting used is not necessarily in your interest. At times it can be dangerous enough to shorten the time each of us has been allotted to live.
- 08:25
The oak speaks in a dream
Chapter 4Carpenter Shi and the Shrine Oak
- The oak appears in Carpenter Shi's dream and takes him to task: are you comparing me with useful fruit trees (cherry, apple, pear, orange, citron)? As soon as their fruit is ripe they are torn apart, their limbs broken and twisted, and they don't finish out their years.
- Webb notes the tree doesn't mention timber cut for furniture. It focuses on fruit trees, which it sees as mistreated, almost tortured, by their own utility: 'they bring it on themselves.'
- 'I've been trying a long time to be of no use, and now that I'm about to die I've finally got it. This is of great use to me. If I had been of some use, would I ever have grown this large?' And it turns the insult back: 'you and I are both things… you, a worthless man about to die, how do you know I'm a worthless tree?'
- 10:30
Why is it at the shrine? Judging by conventional standards
Chapter 4Carpenter Shi and the Shrine Oak
- The apprentice asks: if it's so intent on being useless, why is it serving as the village shrine tree? Carpenter Shi: 'Say no more!' It protects itself differently from ordinary things. 'If you try to judge it by conventional standards, you'll be way off.'
- Zhuangzi wants us to think about usefulness and uselessness as criteria for judging other people and for judging ourselves.
- This challenges the common-sense view that useful is inherently positive and useless inherently negative. Normally, calling something useless is never praise.
- 12:06
Cripple Shu (end of p. 62)
- He skips the next tree story (Ziqi and the tree at Shang Hill) and goes straight to Cripple Shu, apologizing for the 'ableist discourse' of the name but noting the age of the text.
- Shu's chin is buried in his navel, his shoulders are above his head, his pigtail points at the sky. He supports himself by sewing, washing and winnowing grain, is passed over when troops are called up and when work gangs are formed, and receives grain and firewood when relief is handed out. He 'finishes out the years Heaven gave him.'
- Comparison with the tree (a student's point): Shu can't do physical labor just as the tree can't produce timber. Trees are judged by whether carpenters find them useful, people by whether they are 'able-bodied', and failing that you're labeled a burden on society.
- Zhuangzi says that in both cases the 'winner' may be the one society deemed useless, because it gets to live out its life. The last line ('how much better if he had crippled virtue?') is a further tweak.
- 14:39
Historical background: war, conscription and corvée labor
- Context: a time of nearly constant strife among kingdoms, when any young man could be drafted into military service with no sense of the bigger picture ('Who are we shooting at again?'), possibly for a vanity war of the rulers.
- Second danger: corvée labor (he searched for the French term), meaning coerced work on what we'd now call infrastructure projects such as bridges or irrigation. Instead of paying outside laborers, the state uses local sons whether or not they have the skills, and some die.
- Comparison: building the pyramids (Egypt or Mexico) and the Great Wall. Even non-military forced labor could kill you, against your wishes.
- With that background, the person criticized as 'useless' is the one doing okay. Zhuangzi 'throws his elbows around' to make you reconsider common sense.
“This text throws its elbows around and tries to get you to reconsider your common sense.”
- 18:53
Pair exercise: when does uselessness help you survive today?
- Prompt: think of an example, here and now, where uselessness puts you on the better side of survival. When is uselessness something to be praised?
- Webb's framing: in our 21st-century, late-capitalist milieu, uselessness has associations of laziness or cowardice 'glommed onto it.' Is it hard to find counterexamples, or are there lots?
- 26:28
Student examples: interns, firefighters, the draft, introverts
- An intern who made herself very useful got loaded with more and more work and learned to 'dial it down.' Webb called this good nuance: not useless, just not quite so at your service.
- Firefighters and dangerous manual labor: useful but risky. Webb noted a key difference from the text: firefighters volunteer for the job, while Zhuangzi's people are drafted.
- Conscription: being judged unfit gets you passed over, or reassigned to safer auxiliary roles. Conscientious objectors are useful or useless depending on whose narrative you use (principled pacifist versus 'just an excuse'). Webb wondered whether drone warfare, operated from chairs or wheelchairs, undermines being passed over.
- Introverts seen as 'useless' but protecting their peace: Webb pushed back that listening to chatty people makes them useful to you, which isn't the same as being judged useless yourself. Another student cited contractors stretching out projects to keep billing. All of this shows that what counts as useful is very context-specific.
- 34:37
Useful, useless — to whom? Credit cards, planned obsolescence, weaponized ignorance
- His own example: if you pay your credit card to zero every month, card company executives regard you as a 'deadbeat' because you make them no money. 'Useful, useless — to whom?'
- Planned obsolescence: a student described iPhones slowing down when the new model comes out (engineering). Webb added the cultural version ('you're still on an iPhone 14? we're at 18') and appliances that used to last 25 years. You're useless to companies unless you keep buying.
- Weaponized ignorance (a term from moms' groups): the husband who 'just can't figure out the dishwasher' so his wife does it. Uselessness works out well for some and badly for others.
- More student cases: the only friend with a car becomes everyone's driver, so you pretend the car is broken; truly not knowing a domain means you don't have to help or feel bad about it; the Amish and an apocalypse, where 'useless' low-tech people might outlast tech-dependent big cities like LA.
“Useful, useless — to whom?”
- 42:01
Dichotomies only exist relative to each other, and they're arbitrary
Chapter 2“This” and “That” and the Hinge of the Way
- A student argued that to be useless someone else has to be useful: if no one had a car, you couldn't pretend not to have one. Webb played devil's advocate (people used to get around by bike) and restated it: we have no way to measure uselessness except in comparison with usefulness.
- He also noted that the draft example assumes wars are fought with infantry, which is changing.
- Another student compared it to The Incredibles: if everyone has superpowers, no one does. Webb said this logical move is very familiar to Zhuangzi and is how his assault on dichotomies started. Dichotomies only work as long as you define one side against the other; dissolve one and the distinction disappears.
- Another student: driving is useful in LA but nearly useless in a city in Japan with great public transit, so binaries are subjective to environment. Webb went further: they are arbitrary. People say it's so, a group agrees, consensus becomes common sense, and common sense is accepted uncritically.
- 46:08
'Why fret about this and that?' The water-bottle demonstration
Chapter 2“This” and “That” and the Hinge of the Way“There Is a Beginning…”: One, Words and Three
- Connection to the 'ten thousand things' coming together: Zhuangzi identifies dichotomies (big/little, fast/slow, attractive/unattractive, smart/stupid) as interrelated, so dissolving one side dissolves the pair.
- One of his most enigmatic moves goes 'into grammar': why do we fret about the difference between 'this' and 'that'?
- Demonstration with a student's water bottle: she says 'this water bottle', he says 'that water bottle', and eventually someone asks 'you mean that water bottle?' Where is the line on the carpet where 'this' becomes 'that'?
- Native speakers learn the distinction intuitively and spot a non-native speaker's mistake instantly, yet there is no hard-and-fast rule for where 'this' ends and 'that' begins when we're talking about the same thing.
- 49:31
Two-tier vs. three-tier languages: no language owns the right distinction
Chapter 2“This” and “That” and the Hinge of the Way
- English is two-tier (this/that). Japanese is three-tier: kore/sore/are (kono/sono/ano), close to the speaker, close to the listener, and far from both. To a Japanese speaker English can seem impoverished.
- Class survey: Chinese is binary like English (zhe/na 这/那), Korean is three-way like Japanese, Arabic two-tier, Spanish debated (este/ese/aquel for place), and Russian assigned as 'homework.' English packs Japanese sore and are into one word, 'that.'
- Conclusion: Zhuangzi would say no language has a monopoly on how to say 'this' and 'that', and you can't call another language's way perverse. So the whole business of distinguishing starts to feel arbitrary.
- This is 'fuel for the fire' for Zhuangzi's continuing assault on binaries and on discriminating between things. Zhuangzi, working in Chinese, argued this through 'this' and 'that.'
- 55:28
Yan Hui asks to go to Wei: Confucius as character again (p. 50)
Chapter 4Yan Hui and the Fasting of the Mind
- Another appearance of Confucius as a character. Yan Hui, Confucius's favorite disciple, seems to do and say the right thing yet can't please Kongzi or say what he wants to hear.
- Flag the usual question: how is Kongzi being used here? Is he sympathetic to Zhuangzian thought, or portrayed as obtuse?
- Yan Hui's plan: the young ruler of Wei is reckless and lets his people die 'by swampfuls'. Quoting the master ('leave the well-ordered state and go to the state in chaos; at the doctor's gate are many sick men'), he wants to go and restore the state. It sounds like an earnest young Confucian scholar, and you'd expect Confucius to say 'go for it.'
- 58:06
Confucius applies the brakes: fame and wisdom as 'evil weapons'
Chapter 4Yan Hui and the Fasting of the Mind
- Instead Confucius says 'you'll probably get yourself executed.' The Way doesn't want things mixed into it: mixture leads to many ways, then bustle, then trouble with no remedy. The perfect man of ancient times made sure he had it in himself before giving it to others. 'Tap the brakes': you don't have this wisdom yet and you want to teach kings?
- 'Virtue is destroyed by fame, and wisdom comes out of wrangling… both are evil weapons.' Webb calls this very interesting: fame and wisdom are weapons, not routes to success.
- Lecturing a tyrant on benevolence and righteousness is 'using other men's bad points to parade your own excellence.' You'll be called a plaguer of others and get plagued in turn. And if the ruler already loves worthy men, why does he need you?
- The two-sided danger: oppose a tyrant too much and you lose your head; comply too much and you are co-opted into his moral corruption ('piling fire on fire, adding water to water'). Ministers famed for uprightness were trapped by Jie and Zhou because they loved fame, and even sages can't cope with men after fame and gain.
- 01:02:16
Yan Hui's strategies: companion of Heaven, of men, of antiquity
Chapter 4Yan Hui and the Fasting of the Mind
- Yan Hui keeps guessing what Confucius wants to hear. First, 'grave and empty-hearted, diligent and of one mind.' Rejected: an uncertain look will still show on your face, and the ruler won't be converted even by small daily virtue, let alone a grand display.
- Second: 'inwardly direct, outwardly compliant, working through the examples of antiquity.' Inwardly direct makes him a companion of Heaven (he and the Son of Heaven are equally sons of Heaven, so it isn't a vanity project). Outwardly compliant, doing the bowing and kneeling everyone does, makes him a companion of men. Speaking through ancient precedents makes him a companion of antiquity, blunt but unblamable.
- Webb notes that using historical examples instead of your own words was a well-used real technique for criticizing rulers.
- Confucius: 'Goodness, how could that do? You have too many policies and plans.' You might escape blame, but you won't convert him. 'You are still making the mind your teacher.' Yan Hui, exasperated, asks for the proper way.
- 01:04:31
The fasting of the mind
Chapter 4Yan Hui and the Fasting of the Mind
- 'Something we've never seen in the voice of Kongzi': 'You must fast!'
- Yan Hui takes it literally. His family is poor and he hasn't had wine or strong foods for months, so does that count? Confucius: that is the fasting before a sacrifice, not the fasting of the mind.
- 'Make your will one. Don't listen with your ears, listen with your mind. No, don't listen with your mind, listen with your spirit. Listening stops with the ears, the mind stops with recognition, but spirit is empty and waits on all things. The Way gathers in emptiness alone. Emptiness is the fasting of the mind.'
- Question to the class: if ordinary fasting means abstaining from food and drink, what could it mean to fast the mind?
- 01:06:31
Interpreting the fast: shutting down the senses and the over-cerebral
Chapter 4Yan Hui and the Fasting of the MindCook Ding Carves the Ox
- Student suggestions: 'don't have thoughts' or 'empty your consciousness'; or notice thoughts and let them pass by, which Webb identified as one style of meditation.
- Link to Cook Ding, who seems to need sensory input and an overly cerebral approach shut down (not 'the book says it's supposed to be this way, so I'm going to force the blade through').
- Link to a former student, an Olympic swimmer from Greece: asked how competition differs from practice, he said the stadium is silent. He doesn't hear the spectators until he finishes the race and comes out of the water.
- Hearing is just one sense. Fasting the mind doesn't mean 'go take a nap'; it's something more.
- 01:09:18
Unlearning: what we lose by 'gaining' experience
Chapter 4Yan Hui and the Fasting of the Mind
- A student proposed resetting the judgments acquired through experience and looking at everything with fresh senses. Webb called it a great idea that fits Zhuangzi elsewhere: what we acquire from childhood to adulthood is intellectual clutter.
- We think of aging as gaining insight, perspective and judgment. Zhuangzi says what matters is what is lost: we become estranged from what we used to be.
- The baggage includes fretting and self-assessment (how am I perceived, am I a success or a failure, 'I'm this old, should I be doing this by now?'). Zhuangzi doesn't approve of self-congratulation either. It's all junk in our minds to fast from before undertaking something.
- It isn't a 'dry month' or the fasting of religious traditions but something alternative. The phrase is ambiguous and open to speculation; it seems to mean reducing or suppressing, internally, the things we take for granted (experience, sensory input, habits).
- Here Kongzi seems to have turned into a Zhuangzian mentor, rejecting even watered-down Confucian strategies, but without the precision we'd want, so we have to fill in the blanks.
“It's not what's acquired through living a long life — it's what's actually lost.”